Here's the official press release from 1960!
For many months, we have been under terrific pressure from many quarters to announce our decision about the future of Father Knows Best. It has been no secret that we would both prefer to cease further production of the series. This in itself, we have pointed out to many questioners, could not constitute a conclusive decision, any more than it did a year ago, when we both felt exactly the same way. We would like to tell you some of the reasons why we have wanted to discontinue production.
Over its six years on television Father Knows Best has told an organic story of a family. By 'organic' we mean it has grown like a living thing. The Andersons' little girl [Lauren Chapin] has grown from a kitten to an awkward adolescent. Their older daughter [Elinor Donahue] has gone through high school and into college. And the father, you may have noticed, has acquired several more gray hairs.
How long could we continue on the same basis? Inevitably a family's integration begins to break down. The inescapable logic of our plot, and our casting, demanded certain agonizing decisions. We had reached a point at which it was only reasonable for our daughter to get married; we very seriously considered doing that during the current season. And we had reached a point at which it was only reasonable that our son Bud [Billy Gray] go off to college, or into the armed forces, and we had to consider that too during this season.
But we refused to scatter the Anderson family because, we recognized, it would destroy the basis for our show. Father Knows Best is not based on the charm or wit of any single personality. Our series is based on the relationships between members of a growing family. If we allowed the family to grow past the point of growth, it would no longer be the series we wanted to produce, and the very title would become absurd.
Another reason we have wanted to get out of further production is more personal, concerning our own energies and creative resources, as well as those of Jane Wyatt, the rest of the cast, our director and writers.
Can you imagine how demanding it is to continue to produce the same program series, almost every week, for six years? We have been blessed in that each successive year Father Knows Best has gotten a better score from the audience research polls. But the very success struck terror in our hearts. You don't want to fall back, but at each step the fear that you will gets greater. How many fresh and amusing situations could we contrive for the Anderson family? How many times could a father demonstrate his wisdom without getting tiresome? We had reached a point after which, with each new show, our doubts about our own abilities to do it as well as we wanted to grew greater.
Hence, for over a year we have wanted to stop production. And yet we could not arbitrarily walk out on it. Such an overt decision, without regard to the future telecasting of the series, would have been a disservice to our partner Screen Gems, to the sponsors that have supported us through these years, and to the thousands of viewers who have written us letters urging continuation of the series.
Now at last an ideal solution has presented itself. An excellent arrangement has now been made with the Columbia Broadcasting System for the future telecasting of Father Knows Best. The Scott Paper Company will continue to sponsor the series for the next two years in a new time period, Tuesday nights at 8 o'clock. We will make a careful selection of what we consider the best of more than 200 films made, to be telecast in logical sequence beginning next fall.
This arrangement means that the many viewers who have found pleasure in Father Knows Best in the past will be able to continue to enjoy it at their comfort, to see films they may have missed, and to see again films they may recall having enjoyed in past seasons. It also means that children who were too young to stay up to see these films previously will now get a chance to see them.
Here's how the five permanent cast members felt about it in 1960.
Robert Young : "Some days I feel like the prisoner let out of the penitentiary: the gates clang behind him and he's temporarily lost. He has no home. He doesn't know where to go, what to do.
"Generally, when a series is finished a party is given for the cast and crew and everyone vows eternal friendship and love. In our case we closed down ignominiously because of the writers' strike-we just sort of faded off saying, 'See you when the strike is over'-and I'm sure when things are settled, Eugene Rodney and I will have a party for the cast and crew because we want to say good-bye to them properly and express our gratitude for all the wonderful things they've done for us during the past six years.
"My Immediate plans? To play golf and more golf. My future plans are really in a state of flux. I plan to take my family to Europe this summer for a vacation. Beyond that, I haven't a clue as to what I'll be doing."
"I feel that an important part of my life is missing, not reporting to Stage 11 at Screen Gems five mornings a week. I have nothing to do right now, but I'm busier than ever with housewifely things-gardening and meeting friends for lunch. It's been six years since I've had the leisure for that! And shopping, and planning my son Christopher's wedding on June 18.
Elinor Donahue: "I was sorry to see the show stop production. We've all been together for so long and worked together so much that we felt like an actual family-and it was really like a part of a real family unit breaking up. My plans? Well, I hope the pilot I did for Calling Miss Peters sells. And there have been some movie offers. I certainly plan to keep on acting."
Billy Gray: "I'm unhappy about the show's ceasing. It was fun to do and the money was fine! I haven't any specific plans. I did a Peter Gunn and the associate producer said he wants to talk to me about another series. And I'm planning to go to Rome for a vacation. Then I'll look for work."
Lauren Chapin: "I still don't believe we're through with the show. I've grown up with my 'other family' and I miss them all very much. I've had offers for four other series, and I will probably do one of them. Mostly I'd love a Broadway show-and just think, I heard Jane Wyatt wants one too and if we could do the same show together, it would be like part of my own family back together again!"